eirexe:

1. >gross frontal view
2. >¾ is 7/8
3. >wings don’t have a fold animation
4. >Legs are not in one symbol
5. >Shit ends in round, instead of pointy
6. >EYES ARE INSIDE THEIR OWN SYMBOLS
7. >there are different symbols for different perspectives
8. >leg poses are in guide layers, not as subframes of the leg symbols
9. >hair is broken into different pieces
10. >cutie mark is gross as fuck
11. >back legs are in different parts
12. >different ear frames aren’t facing up
13. >chest patch is gross
14. >frontal wings aren’t round and smooth
15. >weird mouth shapes
16. >legs don’t do a curve, but are straight
17. >unfolded wings look gross
18. >eyeblink is in a different symbol than eyelines
19. >eyeblink isn’t divided in various expressions
20. >no back views
21. >no ¾
22. >chest and backleg top are weirdly shaped
23. >pupil is too big
24. >no premade walkcycles
25. >symbol’s rotation pivot is not set in the symbol
26. >LINES, NO SHAPES
27. >mouth border shape is gross as fuck
28. >head shape is gross
29. >frontal mouth bottom movements aren’t in the same symbols
30. >nostril movements aren’t in the same symbol
31. >no object grabbing mouth frame
32. >no perspective notes
33. >lines don’t fucking fit correctly
34. >weird shit in the mouths
35. >scary shit in the mouths

To sum up:

Gross as fucking your own sister

My rebuttal to each point, some valid:

1. purely opinion, please explain in greater detail
2. efficient for animators to copy animation of head turns
3. Im sure the person who’s animating it will do that for you
4. easily frame by frame the legs, don’t expect to use tweens for everything
5. which part specifically..?
6. easier for animation by using sub groups
7. that seems like a good thing actually, gives users easier access to rotation without swapping the whole puppet
8. again, frame by frame legs. walking animations will switch the number of layers too frequently to have it tween properly
9. allows hair folicles to move independantly allowing unique weight and physics
10. opinion based, please explain more
11. helps with animating the back legs so they dont appear as one static part, more parts = more motion
12. just like the show style, right?
13. it’s for overlapping the legs and hiding the connection points for when the hooves overlap the chest
14. did you want show quality or not?
15. mouthes are used for more than just speech; they can be used for emotion too
16. there are a couple different legs if you look closely
17. hardcore opinion
18. this allows for combinations of eyebrow animation and blink animation
19. that’s what they “eyeline” eyebrow is for, there’s also a few invisible graphics you may have missed because there was no object on the first frame, only used for expressions
20. here I guess was laziness of the creator. You hear that, creator? You forgot a back view! These free puppets are incomplete and you are a baffoon!
21. yes there is you just said earlier…
22. for overlapping animation to make it smooth to the viewer, but who said animation was an easy task
23. use the scale tool; the pupils are at maximum size by default, scale it to the right size. Change and tween the size to create emotions like shock (smaller) or enamorment (larger)
24. Creator, you forgot to animate the puppets for these poor people! You made them download these assets for free and now you tell them they have to “animate it themselves”? For shame!
25. which symbol specifically? also this is for accurate animation, so a pivot point might be farther out on, say, the legs so that they pivot around the hip rather than the toes
26. that explains the round lines. I agree that they should probably use a line mitre next time, or convert the lines to shapes and taper the ends that way
27. used for masking
28. hair overlaps the grossness, the only thing you should be worrying about at this point is what it looks like to the viewers
29. you can call it a chin or jaw if you want. And they arent synced so that you can drop the jaw and make unique expressions
30. again, flaring nostrils, expressions
31. wat
32. wat
33. for which part?
34. explain
35. you’re running out of things to rant about already?